When You Wish Upon a Pickle: A Sesame Street Special

Christopher Knowings

Chris

Suki Lopez

Nina

Ryan Dillon

Elmo

Peter Linz

Ernie / Herry Monster

Eric Jacobson

Bert / Grover / Oscar / Guy Smiley

David Rudman

Cookie Monster

Leslie Carrara-Rudolph

Abby Cadabby

Stephanie D'Abruzzo

Gale Warning

Matt Vogel

Wish Pickle / Mr. Johnson / Big Bird / The Count

Amanda Seyfried

Natalie Neptune

Blake Lively

Delivery Person

Ilana Glazer

Ms. Noodle

Jennifer Barnhart

Zoe / Gladys the Cow

Pam Arciero

Grundgetta / Shoes / Jacket

Justiin Davis

Self

Deborah Grausman

Smartie

Tyler Bunch

Frankie Cordero

John E. Kennedy

Carmen Osbahr

Martin P. Robinson

Aidan Albert

Child Extra

Nikki Ayoub

Child Extra

Swayam Bhatia

Child Extra